Friday, February 14, 2014

"In Search of Home" and Institutional Racism

Theme: The Perpetual "Prison" of Institutional Racism

"People who lived in Murphy Homes felt like prisoners, kept in check by roving bands of gun-strapped kids and a nightmare army of drug fiends." (page 27)
In this quote, the residents of Murphy Homes-- low-income projects built specifically for those of African-American descent-- are compared to prisoners in a jail. This reinforces the theme of institutional racism, which is akin to imprisonment to those who fall victim to it. Because the federal government didn't provide sufficient housing for the residents of Murphy Homes, they must instead turn to illicit measures of raising income, like selling drugs. The police are absent in this world ruled by gangs and drug dealers, except to commit violence against the people who are a part of it-- much like the classical sadistic prison guards that hurt more than they protect.

"Tony felt his brother's life could be saved, even if he felt his own had already, at age fourteen, passed the point of no return." (page 27)
Here it is clear that although Tony is not in an actual prison, he certainly feels trapped. Unlike a higher-income white child, who could always turn to counseling or rehab, Tony has no choices. The institutional racism that put him in the projects to begin with-- and, more symbolically, put the projects in him-- has also stuck him in a cycle of poverty, where he feels as if he has no choice but to continue his lifestyle of drug selling and gang violence.

"There was never a question that Cherry Hill wasn't built as a sustainable community for its families. Isolated and desolate, it had no main streets. Small, poorly constructed, faux-brick homes lined the streets like dormitories." (page 29)
The imagery used in this quote is strikingly similar to a description of a prison complex. The houses are small and all look alike, similar to prison blocks or jail cells. The poor construction is only a preview to what is found inside, buildings in utter disrepair because of the lack of upkeep by landlords who couldn't care less about the people living in them. The tie to institutional racism is clear here; the words "wasn't built as" place the blame on the federal government, who planned and constructed Cherry Hill in the first place. The government, with all of its on-paper "good intentions," in practice only work to reinforce the prison complex that already haunts low-income black communities in The Other Wes Moore.

"He lifted all eighty pounds of Wes off the ground, slamming him facefirst on the trunk of the police cruiser. Wes's chest collapsed against the trunk of the car, sending pain throughout his entire body...  he tried to plead his case to the police officer as he closed the second cuff on Wes's eight-year-old wrists." (pages 34-5)
This description of police brutality is even stronger when one considers more recent accounts of racial profiling and police violence in New York. It is hard to imagine an eight-year-old rich white boy, no matter the circumstances, being thrown against a police car as if he is nothing but a sack of garbage-- one that poses a serious threat to humanity, no less. The inhumane treatment of a boy who is really still just a child, as well as his subsequent arrest and release without any type of outside help or counseling that would typically be available to a higher-income child who found himself in a difficult situation, makes clear the connection between institutional racism-- which allows the police officer to handle Wes as if he is nothing more than an animal-- and the prison it forms-- which ensures that Wes will always remain an animal unless he works very hard to change it.

"Whole blocks were abandoned, buildings blackened and hollowed out by fires set by arsonists-- many of whom were in the employ of landlords looking to cash out of the deteriorating ghetto. I didn't have much of a frame of reference back then, though. I didn't know that drug fiends were still making use of those abandoned buildings for activities that would've blown my mind, or that the swollen hands on the man leaning against a telephone pole by himself-- eyes flickering, head nodding-- were telltale signs of needle injections." (page 43)
The world that Wes describes is not a particularly nurturing one for any young child. While higher-income children would grow up in the suburbs among white picket fences and perfectly groomed gardens, Wes and his counterparts grow up among drug dealers and gang wars. The institutional and social segregation by race and income reinforces the "prison" that boys like Tony find themselves stuck in. Living among drug addicts, it is much more likely that one will someday become a drug addict too-- the cycle is encouraged to continue more than it is to end, with practices that inevitably lead to a more literal form of imprisonment.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

"Is Daddy Coming With Us?" and the Struggles of Women

Theme: Feminine Strength and Violence Against Women

"My mother was obsessed with the poet Nikki Giovanni, in love with her unabashed feminine strength and her reconciliation of love and revolution." (page 7)
Here the theme of the strength of women, which recurs throughout the chapter, is introduced for the first time. Wes's mother likes Nikki Giovanni not for the beauty of her poetry, but for what she symbolizes for women. Ms. Moore's past is one of conflict between love and revolution: though she believed she loved Bill, ultimately he was not a part of the revolution she made to find a better life for herself and her children. The fact that her daughter's nickname is Nikki, after her own beloved feminist icon, signifies the ability to revolt without the help of men, and its importance above simple and often misguided love.

"My maternal great-grandfather Mas Fred, as he was known, would plant a coconut tree at his home in Mount Horeb, a neighboring area, for each of his kids and grandkids when they were born. My mother always bragged that hers was the tallest and strongest of the bunch." (page 8)
Wes's mother could have chosen many attributes of her namesake coconut tree to be proud of, but she chooses "tall" and "strong." These adjectives are telling markers of her own personal values of feminine strength. As discussed in the next paragraph, she has grown up in a society where being treated well by men necessitates earning their respect. Wes's mother values physical prowess, demonstrated through strength and height, above all because they prove that she is not helpless, despite what her gender may label her as. Feminine strength is incredibly important to her because it is all that she has, and as a survivor of domestic violence she feels that she must spend the rest of her life proving to herself that she is good enough and strong enough to protect herself from man.

"Bill was too strong, too determined, too high." (page 10)
This quote warps the usually-positive theme of feminine strength into something slightly less appealing. Wes's mother faces a problem that, as Wes points out, many other women often face: the reliance on strength and personal merit to combat problems of sexism and marital violence. She believes that being "strong" will save her from abuse, when in fact it is part of her downfall; Bill doesn't care how strong she is, and in fact it will probably only make him hit harder. Picking up a knife helps her against Bill's attacks, but relying on "strength" for "protection" means that she will always have to be on the defensive, unable to strike back until someone else strikes first. In this scene, Wes draws on a very important aspect of the theme of feminine strength: women often believe that they have to be stronger or better to protect themselves from males, when in reality it is the entire system of male-perpetrated domestic violence against women that must change.

"Soon I could tell by the sound of the steps it was my father. His walk was slower, heavier, more deliberate. My mother tended to move up the stairs in a sprint." (page 11)
The ways in which the two characters move-- the strongest male and the strongest female in young Wes's life-- is symbolic of their places in society. Wes's father moves slowly and deliberately because he knows that he can. As a male in a patriarchal society, the world waits for him rather than the other way around. He is thoughtful and slow because he can afford to be thoughtful and slow without being labeled as useless-- even the slowest man can fix a lightbulb, or paint a house, or engage in any combination of the manual labor that betrays its sexist tendencies in the very word manual. Wes's mother, in contrast, knows that no matter how fast she runs she will always be left behind. As a woman she must constantly prove herself-- unlike her husband, she is guilty of uselessness until proven innocent. She runs up the stairs because she feels the need to prove her strength to herself and to those around her, and (perhaps unconsciously) to ensure her own safety.

"'Wes, he needs to learn what is acceptable and what is not!' My father agreed, but with a gentle laugh, reminded her that cursing at a young boy wasn't the most effective way of making a point. I was saved, for the moment." (page 6)
The first time the reader encounters Wes's mother, it is in a chapter dedicated to the men in his lives: the time "Is Daddy Coming With Us?" signifies his narrative focus on the role of his father in his early life. Mrs. Moore is portrayed as the antithesis to the voice of reason, a fiery woman who must be calmed down by his more gentle father. The idea of a woman who can speak for herself in literature is refreshing, but the ease with which her husband quiets her-- Calm down, honey, you're overreacting-- is not. The theme of feminine strength is diluted here by Wes's father, however well-intentioned. But there is no mistaking the strength in Wes's mother's voice; it is clear that she knows exactly how she wants to raise her child and she will not stand for any other way.